Back to what I was writing, before nearly falling off my chair just now!
There’s already been plenty of coverage about a religious service in London today to honour the UK troops who have fought and died, and suffered horrific physical and mental scars, in Iraq since the US-led invasion six years ago.
Quite right to remember the soldiers’ courage and sacrifice, but the trouble with such occasions is that is not just a matter of the Queen and dignitaries meeting those who made that sacrifice. There is an unmistakeable subtext that’s all about monopolising the discourse on Britian’s war-making since 2001, which has little public support or international legitimacy.
The plan could be summed up as: “Let’s concentrate on something most people can agree about, and divert attention from the fiasco that has been the war in Iraq – oh, and in Afghanistan too.” This leaves one with the feeling that British soldiers, having been asked to do so much to carry out the plans of a cynical and unpopular government in the field of battle and the badlands of occupation, are now being exploited for propaganda.
So, for balance, here are a few of the things we should bear in mind during the service at St Paul’s: the overwhelming opposition to the war among the British public; the humanitarian disaster that the war caused and continues to cause in Iraq; the lies Tony Blair told to justify the war; the fact that the behaviour of British troops, while better than US combat troops, its
prison guards, and foreign mercenaries, has been far from exemplary. Most significantly perhaps, Iraqis are still paying the price day by day.
Pray hard, Mr Blair, and look hard into your conscience.
Friday, 9 October 2009
WHAT!!!!?????
BREAKING NEWS, BARACK OBAMA WINS NOBEL PEACE PRIZE.
FIRST THOUGHT, A BIT PREMATURE, SURELY?
FIRST THOUGHT, A BIT PREMATURE, SURELY?
Thursday, 8 October 2009
The World as seen from Israel
You've got to hand it to the Israeli press for its unashamed ethno-centricity. A couple of good examples have cropped up today - Ynet had a story headlined 'Israeli on 100 most influential gays list'. Haaretz have perhaps topped this with the fabulous Israeli author Amoz Oz loses out on Nobel literature prize.
Tuesday, 6 October 2009
Can it be true? More Goldstone
The Palestinian Authority dropped its insistence on a UN vote endorsing the Goldstone report after being blackmailed by Israeli representatives in the US, according to the Shehab news agency.
It says the Israelis have a video showing Mahmoud Abbas and Tzipi Livni urging Ehud Barak to pursue the military assault on Gaza.
It was shown to a Palestinian delegation in Washington on a laptop belonging to Colonel Ely Abraham of the IDF causing them to give way on Goldstone, Shehab says.
There is also allegedly an audio tape of a phonecall between Dov Weisglass and Tayyeb Abdul Rahim in which Abdul Rahim urges the Israelis to storm Jabaliya and Shati refugee camps in Gaza in order to route Hamas once and for all.
Weisglass is heard bemoaning the fate of thousands of civilians in the camps if the troops moved in, to which Abdul Rahim is reported to have replied: “They all voted for Hamas and they chose their destiny not us.”
Threatened with publication of such incriminating evidence of collaboration with Israel, Shehab says the PA representatives signed an undertaking not to lobby other countries to adopt the Goldstone report.
Another theory doing the rounds suggests Israel threatened to derail the Wataniya project to start up a second mobile phone network in the West Bank, if the PA persisted in using Goldstone to seek war crimes charges against Israel. Abbas’s son stands to make millions from the deal.
None of this is doing the PA or Abu Mazen's battered reputations any good.
It is not hard to imagine his Fatah faction seeing a silver lining in Israel's Operation Cast Lead, in much the same way that some Sunni Arab governments did as the Shia Muslim group Hezbollah - along with all of Lebanon - was being thumped by Israel in the summer of 2006. But egging the Israel defence minister on, somewhere he could be secretly filmed, as Palestinians were being slaughtered? It would require a naivety even beyond Abu Mazen.
As for the Abdul Rahim-Weisglass tale, at least it's a bit longer on the specifics, an actual situation on the ground, a direct quote. But why should that conversation ever have even taken place? The Israelis never had any intention of penetrating the Gaza camps. Cast Lead was always meant to be a "no casualty" war for them so they took places like Tel el-Hawa and Zeitoun. So what would someone even as unsavoury as Abdul Rahim be doing discussing this question with the equally unsavoury Weisglas. Israeli politicians have been hinting at PA collusion in the Gaza attacks, but this kind of stuff is way off the mark.
Anyway, watch this space, as this can only grind on and on.
It says the Israelis have a video showing Mahmoud Abbas and Tzipi Livni urging Ehud Barak to pursue the military assault on Gaza.
It was shown to a Palestinian delegation in Washington on a laptop belonging to Colonel Ely Abraham of the IDF causing them to give way on Goldstone, Shehab says.
There is also allegedly an audio tape of a phonecall between Dov Weisglass and Tayyeb Abdul Rahim in which Abdul Rahim urges the Israelis to storm Jabaliya and Shati refugee camps in Gaza in order to route Hamas once and for all.
Weisglass is heard bemoaning the fate of thousands of civilians in the camps if the troops moved in, to which Abdul Rahim is reported to have replied: “They all voted for Hamas and they chose their destiny not us.”
Threatened with publication of such incriminating evidence of collaboration with Israel, Shehab says the PA representatives signed an undertaking not to lobby other countries to adopt the Goldstone report.
Another theory doing the rounds suggests Israel threatened to derail the Wataniya project to start up a second mobile phone network in the West Bank, if the PA persisted in using Goldstone to seek war crimes charges against Israel. Abbas’s son stands to make millions from the deal.
None of this is doing the PA or Abu Mazen's battered reputations any good.
It is not hard to imagine his Fatah faction seeing a silver lining in Israel's Operation Cast Lead, in much the same way that some Sunni Arab governments did as the Shia Muslim group Hezbollah - along with all of Lebanon - was being thumped by Israel in the summer of 2006. But egging the Israel defence minister on, somewhere he could be secretly filmed, as Palestinians were being slaughtered? It would require a naivety even beyond Abu Mazen.
As for the Abdul Rahim-Weisglass tale, at least it's a bit longer on the specifics, an actual situation on the ground, a direct quote. But why should that conversation ever have even taken place? The Israelis never had any intention of penetrating the Gaza camps. Cast Lead was always meant to be a "no casualty" war for them so they took places like Tel el-Hawa and Zeitoun. So what would someone even as unsavoury as Abdul Rahim be doing discussing this question with the equally unsavoury Weisglas. Israeli politicians have been hinting at PA collusion in the Gaza attacks, but this kind of stuff is way off the mark.
Anyway, watch this space, as this can only grind on and on.
Monday, 5 October 2009
Saudi 'danger'
Interesting article in The National on the row between Saudi reformers and conservatives over the opening of the King Abdullah University of Science and Technology near Jeddah. A vocal critic of the mixed-sex classes and "un-Islamic" teaching (Sheikh Saad al-Shethri) has been unceremoniously dumped from the Council of Ulema, raising questions about the illiberal tendency of the supposedly liberal movement.
Newspaper editors ganged up on the recently appointed sheikh after he appeared on Saudi TV to air his objections. Saud Kateb, professor of media technology at King Abdul Aziz University in Jeddah, opines: "Society is facing one of its most dangerous phases as moderates are diminishing and extremism is on the rise both on the Left and the Right. The liberals are becoming extremists just like the conservatives... eliminating the opposition, provoking political authority to oppress the rights of others to present their views."
Another way of looking it: don't criticise projects as close to "royal" hearts such as the Kaust, or you'll find yourself out on your ear. It was ever thus, no? It's just that the monarchy is shifting its alignment away from people like Sheikh Saad.
The article quotes the king speaking in 2007: “The establishment of this university has been a living idea in my mind for more than 25 years and I thank God for helping us to realise it.”
Newspaper editors ganged up on the recently appointed sheikh after he appeared on Saudi TV to air his objections. Saud Kateb, professor of media technology at King Abdul Aziz University in Jeddah, opines: "Society is facing one of its most dangerous phases as moderates are diminishing and extremism is on the rise both on the Left and the Right. The liberals are becoming extremists just like the conservatives... eliminating the opposition, provoking political authority to oppress the rights of others to present their views."
Another way of looking it: don't criticise projects as close to "royal" hearts such as the Kaust, or you'll find yourself out on your ear. It was ever thus, no? It's just that the monarchy is shifting its alignment away from people like Sheikh Saad.
The article quotes the king speaking in 2007: “The establishment of this university has been a living idea in my mind for more than 25 years and I thank God for helping us to realise it.”
PA 'to investigate' Goldstone cave-in
So Mahmoud Abbas is setting up a commission of inquiry to find out why his own people dropped their demand to for a UN HRC resolution condemning Israel over its rejection of the Goldstone report.
Jerusalem Post says ructions in the Old City are the PA's attempt to distract attention from the embarrassment - unlikely, I'd say.
Commission team - Hana Amireh, Azmi Shuaibi and Rami Hamdallah (who they?) - will report to the pro-Abbas PLO Executive Committee within a fortnight. Apparently pressure for it came from Fatah, and discredited Fatah hard man Muhammad Dahlan has been sounding off on the matter.
Some Abbas loyalists are saying it was PM Salam Fayyad who took the decision. Fayyad loyalists saying he's being framed by Abbas.
Personally, I can't remember a bigger scandal at the PA since the discovery that about half its 1997 budget was squandered through corruption and mismanagement.
Omar Barghouti in an Electronic Intifada editorial goes as far as arguing for the dissolution of the PA, because of its subordination of Palestinian interests to those of Israel and the United States.
Meanwhile, more proof, if needed, how sensitive Israel is to accusations of war crimes (and the evidence is pretty clear for most fair minded people I'd have thought) - Cabinet minister Moshe Yaalon's office admitted he had cancelled a trip to the UK for fear of being held to account to the July 2002 massacre committed in Gaza to claim the scalp of Hamas commander Salah Shehada.
Jerusalem Post says ructions in the Old City are the PA's attempt to distract attention from the embarrassment - unlikely, I'd say.
Commission team - Hana Amireh, Azmi Shuaibi and Rami Hamdallah (who they?) - will report to the pro-Abbas PLO Executive Committee within a fortnight. Apparently pressure for it came from Fatah, and discredited Fatah hard man Muhammad Dahlan has been sounding off on the matter.
Some Abbas loyalists are saying it was PM Salam Fayyad who took the decision. Fayyad loyalists saying he's being framed by Abbas.
Personally, I can't remember a bigger scandal at the PA since the discovery that about half its 1997 budget was squandered through corruption and mismanagement.
Omar Barghouti in an Electronic Intifada editorial goes as far as arguing for the dissolution of the PA, because of its subordination of Palestinian interests to those of Israel and the United States.
Meanwhile, more proof, if needed, how sensitive Israel is to accusations of war crimes (and the evidence is pretty clear for most fair minded people I'd have thought) - Cabinet minister Moshe Yaalon's office admitted he had cancelled a trip to the UK for fear of being held to account to the July 2002 massacre committed in Gaza to claim the scalp of Hamas commander Salah Shehada.
Jerusalem clashes interview
Islamic Movement spokesman Zain Nujidat gives as good as he gets on Israeli radio programme Yoman.
Q: Commander of the Tel Aviv District Police Cmdr. Ilan Franko said that the leaders and clerics are trying to agitate, not to calm. Do you agree?
“Just as he said that he invites everyone to visit Jerusalem, I also invite everyone to see how people are not permitted to enter and pray and then to leave in peace. This is our mosque, why not let us pray there normally without drama and without incitement?”
Q: Maybe because you are causing provocations? Maybe you throw stones and bottles at worshippers?
“That’s not true. That’s the police version. In the incident on Sunday last week, not a single stone was thrown. They tried to bring settlers in by force and then what happened, happened. It’s natural for people to pray at their own mosque. When they’re provoked and when their sensibilities are offended, it’s natural. But to say that the Muslim leadership caused a provocation, that is far off the mark.”
Q: We seem to be talking about different events. I read quotes by Sheikh Raed Salah who said something along the lines—if we have to give up el-Aksa, better we should be shahids. And Khatib also incited.
“The sheikh wanted to make it clear just how precious the el-Aksa Mosque is to every Muslim. We come here to pray according to our religion. According to our Koran, this is our mosque. This is our faith.”
Q: But you know that it’s not just yours.
“There is no compromise over this. There is nothing to talk about.”
Q: Your mosques are there, but so is the Temple Mount, and Jews are also permitted to go there and everyone should respect the other. But it seems that the Muslim worshippers, who were treated respectfully throughout Ramadan, are misbehaving.
“You present this the way you want. We’ve said a thousand times that we are willing to let in a group of neutral archaeologists, acceptable to both the Islamic nation and the Arab world, and if it can prove that there is a single [Jewish] glass or bottle of water in the el-Aksa Mosque, then we’ll talk.”
Q: But the Temple Mount is also holy to the Jews. Will you decide which archaeologists will enter?
“I want to tell you. If there were any signs of the temple, I promise you that neither Franko nor Aharonovich or any other decision-maker in the Israeli government, would let a single Muslim in.”
Q: Why is this all taking place now? Is this related to Abu Mazen, to the elections? Or the Goldstone report and Abu Mazen’s decision about it? Why now?
“Just to make it clear—what is happening on the el-Aksa Mosque began last week, before the report. At the instigation of the police. There was simply a leaflet by extremist Jewish groups—perhaps Israel Radio didn’t get a copy—that was distributed saying that they would meet every day at 7:30 there, because it is ours. And as I said, this my mosque, my religion, my Koran.”
Q: So you made a big deal of some leaflet that made no impression on anyone here, and that’s why all these provocations started?
“Why should it make an impression on you? For you it’s convenient. It makes you happy.”
Q: I’ll ignore that. Why did you take an insignificant matter make provocations out of it that could lead to a conflagration?
“Go into the web sites of these extremist groups, who come to desecrate the el-Aksa Mosque. There is no other way to describe it. They want to meet every day at a certain time, with the help of the police, who are the real desecrators. If not for them, the settlers wouldn’t get close to the el-Aksa Mosque.”
Q: Commander of the Tel Aviv District Police Cmdr. Ilan Franko said that the leaders and clerics are trying to agitate, not to calm. Do you agree?
“Just as he said that he invites everyone to visit Jerusalem, I also invite everyone to see how people are not permitted to enter and pray and then to leave in peace. This is our mosque, why not let us pray there normally without drama and without incitement?”
Q: Maybe because you are causing provocations? Maybe you throw stones and bottles at worshippers?
“That’s not true. That’s the police version. In the incident on Sunday last week, not a single stone was thrown. They tried to bring settlers in by force and then what happened, happened. It’s natural for people to pray at their own mosque. When they’re provoked and when their sensibilities are offended, it’s natural. But to say that the Muslim leadership caused a provocation, that is far off the mark.”
Q: We seem to be talking about different events. I read quotes by Sheikh Raed Salah who said something along the lines—if we have to give up el-Aksa, better we should be shahids. And Khatib also incited.
“The sheikh wanted to make it clear just how precious the el-Aksa Mosque is to every Muslim. We come here to pray according to our religion. According to our Koran, this is our mosque. This is our faith.”
Q: But you know that it’s not just yours.
“There is no compromise over this. There is nothing to talk about.”
Q: Your mosques are there, but so is the Temple Mount, and Jews are also permitted to go there and everyone should respect the other. But it seems that the Muslim worshippers, who were treated respectfully throughout Ramadan, are misbehaving.
“You present this the way you want. We’ve said a thousand times that we are willing to let in a group of neutral archaeologists, acceptable to both the Islamic nation and the Arab world, and if it can prove that there is a single [Jewish] glass or bottle of water in the el-Aksa Mosque, then we’ll talk.”
Q: But the Temple Mount is also holy to the Jews. Will you decide which archaeologists will enter?
“I want to tell you. If there were any signs of the temple, I promise you that neither Franko nor Aharonovich or any other decision-maker in the Israeli government, would let a single Muslim in.”
Q: Why is this all taking place now? Is this related to Abu Mazen, to the elections? Or the Goldstone report and Abu Mazen’s decision about it? Why now?
“Just to make it clear—what is happening on the el-Aksa Mosque began last week, before the report. At the instigation of the police. There was simply a leaflet by extremist Jewish groups—perhaps Israel Radio didn’t get a copy—that was distributed saying that they would meet every day at 7:30 there, because it is ours. And as I said, this my mosque, my religion, my Koran.”
Q: So you made a big deal of some leaflet that made no impression on anyone here, and that’s why all these provocations started?
“Why should it make an impression on you? For you it’s convenient. It makes you happy.”
Q: I’ll ignore that. Why did you take an insignificant matter make provocations out of it that could lead to a conflagration?
“Go into the web sites of these extremist groups, who come to desecrate the el-Aksa Mosque. There is no other way to describe it. They want to meet every day at a certain time, with the help of the police, who are the real desecrators. If not for them, the settlers wouldn’t get close to the el-Aksa Mosque.”
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
